When Earl and Billie find that they can’t get along, Earl tries to discover the reason why karma brought them together in the first place. As he works on the list, he notices that dealing with items where he had wronged or upset a woman helps to change Billie’s behaviour for the better and improve their relationship., In the third-season finale, substantial troubles jeopardize Earl’s karma-driven relationship with Billie (Alyssa Milano), as Earl seeks romantic counsel from his friends. Earl, as a way to deal, devotes all his time to his list, further irking a neglected Billie in the process., Earl and Billie are having trouble getting along, so Earl tries to discover the reason why karma brought them together. While working through his list, he notices that dealing with items where he wronged women helps to change Billie’s behaviour, and improves their relationship., When Earl and Billie find that they just can’t get along, Earl tries to discover the reason why karma brought them together in the first place. As he works on the list, he notices that dealing with items where he had wronged or upset a woman helps to change Billie’s behaviour for the better and improve their relationship. R,S,,HD., Substantial troubles continue to jeopardize Earl’s karma-driven relationship with Billie, prompting Earl to devote all his time to his to-do list, further irking a neglected Billie.